Weigh-Ins on Flights From Hawaii?

Would you be OK being weighed before hopping on a plane bound to or from Hawaii?

After a recent incident involving two Samoan businessmen who were weighed before flying on Hawaiian Airlines, the issue has come into focus.

According to FoxNews.com, two American Samoan businessmen have filed complaints with the U.S. Department of Transportation allegeding they may have been the target of discrimination after being weighed while boarding a recent flight from Honolulu.

In the complaints, the men also say they were assigned new seats on the aircraft that they did not originally select, to ensure that the weight on the flight was evenly distributed, the station reports.

It’s no secret that waistlines are expanding in the U.S. and elsewhere around the world. So, some airlines, including Hawaiian Airlines, have begun to survey passengers about their weight. In this case, a spokeswoman for Hawaiian Airlines tells FoxNews.com that the flight in question was part of a survey period in which the airline weighed each flier traveling between Hawaii and the American Samoan capital Pago Pago.

“This action resulted from the recognition that over time our fuel burn on Pago Pago (PPG) flights was consistently much higher than projected, indicating that our weight assumptions were inaccurate.  We review weights on any flight within our route network that demonstrates such a discrepancy,” Hawaiian communications director Alison Croyle told FoxNews.com reporters. Contrary to existing reports, Hawaiian says it has performed the weight survey on other routes.

“For example, we surveyed our Japan and Korea flights in 2015 and our new Narita flight earlier this year,” she said.

FoxNews.com reports that the survey period lasted six-months and was conducted in accordance with FAA protocols, says Croyle. The results confirmed that the “aircraft cabin weight was heavier than projected” and passengers were reassigned seats to fill empty rows and ensure even weight distribution.

But Avamua Dave Haleck, one of the men who filed a DOT complaint, isn’t buying the explanation.

“…. Hawaiian is saying that ‘yes it is a safety issue’ but, you know, weight distribution,” Haleck told Radio New Zealand, “so have we been flying unsafe for all these years?”

Hawaiian Airlines has been flying the Boeing 767-300 aircraft to American Samoa since 2003. The station  argued that the plane used on the Honolulu-Pago Pago route can safely fly 269 passengers a distance of 6,835 miles. The distance between the two cities is just under 2,600 miles, the news station reports.

So, is this a case of discrimination or smart business? Some have suggested that the move by the airline may be driven by the fact that American Samoa, according to the CIA’s World Factbook, has the highest rate of obesity in the world. Over 74  percent of its adult population is considered obese. Those figures from 2007-2008 may be outdated, however, with more recent claims landing the rate around 95 percent.

In fact, FoxNews.com reports that, in 2013, Samoa Air became the world’s first airline to charge passengers according to size. Those flying on the South Pacific carrier were asked to pay for each kilo that they — combined with their baggage — weighed.

The DOT says that it is currently investigating the complaints against Hawaiian Airlines to determine if any type of discriminatory practice occurred.

So, what does this mean for you, the traveler, to Hawaii? Passenger weigh-ins MAY become a common practice for airlines looking to analyze fuel costs and weight distribution — so, before you book any Hawaii flight or Hawaii vacation package, make sure you research airline practices before you board.

After all, you don’t want to be caught in a surprise airline weigh-in!

Posted by: Bruce Fisher on Oct 12, 2016